Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Adina Levin's avatar

Eek! The scientists who coined the term “AI” weren’t actually from Dartmouth, they just convened there for a conference/workshop. A quick Google Search lists accredited sources (like universities, public institutions) with the correct info. Much like writers, ChatGPT generates answers and they’re not necessarily the right ones. But unlike writers, machines don’t “think” like we do to question those answers.

Expand full comment
Jef Loeb's avatar

You know what really catches the eye here? How you signed it off: RobGPT. Whether or not that was intent, it strikes me you might have just coined a convention that could rescue us all from one of the deeper ethical AI challenges—when it use mutates into deception, pretense, and outright cheating.

If there's such a thing as a "law of tools" like the "law of arms" in political science"— if a tool or a weapon exists, it will be used—but it's outright silly to pretend that people aren't going to climb the adoptive curve like it was flat earth. The productivity gains, not to mention the sheer relief of tedium, make resistance futile.

By the way, as part of the futility as it applies in advertising, would def include clients issuing "thou shalt nots:" in agency contracts.

Meanwhile, while, present day AI really isn't passing the highest levels of the Turing test, it dazzles in thethe instant, but getting discernably thin immediately thereafter, that won't always be so. So I could see a time on the near event horizon when we'll want to let people know that while we were smart enough to capitalize, we also have the integrity to make that fact known . Maybe its teachers requiring students to include, and be graded, on the quality, thinking, and originality of their prompts, as well as on the essay. Maybe we tell the account coordinator that since they're responsible for the final product—lame and formulaic is lame and formulaic—they better do the final draft their own damed selves. Maybe we want to know that we put brain power and energy and heart into this thing, even if the tool helped us get it done faster and with more depth and authority.

RobGPT tells me you used AI in the making. But that the final product is all yours.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts